It's crazy to think that E.P. Carrillo is in its fifth year as a company. It seems like yesterday that they were releasing their inaugural release and when I look back on other releases from the company over the years, I keep thinking about a lot of great cigars. For a while there, I believe they could do no wrong in terms of their releases and I believe they were producing nothing but great cigars, something Illusione has been able to do in my opinion. But of course, every company has a period where they are not at the top of their game. I believe that period began mid last year and after this review, we will see where the company stands. I have always been a fan of E.P. Carrillo, and I have been a fan because of how they release their cigars, how the price their cigars and how they make their cigars. With that being said, let's take a look at their new limited edition and see how they honor their five years as a company with the release of the E.P. Carrillo 5 Year Anniversary.
Released in one vitola, a 6 1/2" by 54 ring gauge toro, the cigar has beautiful bands adorning it and a new E.P. Carrillo band that I like. Total production was set at 30,000 cigars, and they came in ten count boxes. The cigar features an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper, a wrapper I think Ernie does great with, and underneath that is a Ecuadorian Corojo '99 binder with Nicaraguan fillers. The toro is very vintage in hand and it features a wrapper that has older characteristic overall with a noticeable bit of change in coloring at the veins. There is a nice triple cap to the cigar and the wrapper gives off this old La Gloria vibes. There is a strong aroma present with the cigar and on the foot it is showing some noticeable spices, aged tobacco and pepper qualities, with the wrapper showing some leather and earthy notes. Overall, I think it is a beautiful cigar and look forward to lighting this up.
The first third is incredibly spicy and it is showing a nice bit of black pepper notes. With that are some leather and tobacco qualities, and it has some hay characteristics present as well. It has this unique sour note present as well, a sour fruit quality, and it is an enjoyable finishing touch to the cigar that makes for a more complex experience. Overall, this is a nice blend and good one from E.P. Carrillo who I feel has been lacking some successful releases for a while. The construction is very good with the cigar as well and it is showing a fairly even burn line with a nice charcoal ash on the end. The ash is holding on firmly and with that is a nice bit of smoke being produced. The draw is cool and spicy, and I would classify the strength as being full with the body being around the medium-full level.
I am in the second third of the cigar now and while the cigar is mellowing out some, it is not as strong as it was in the first third, it is still fairly strong. There are a nice bit of pepper notes present with the cigar and it is pairing wonderfully with the strong tobacco, dry hay and wood notes. There are some coffee flavors now present as well, and they add to the blend as a whole. It is a strong Sumatra wrapper cigar and a little bit dry, but I like what is being delivered right now. In terms of construction the cigar is smoking very well in this third and it is showing a much more even burn line with a nice charcoal ash on the end. The ash is holding on firmly and there is a lot of smoke being produced with the cigar. This is one E.P. Carrillo that produces a ton of smoke and I have not had an E.P. Carrillo produce this much smoke. Overall though, the strength is at a full level and the body is right there as well.
When I get into the final third of the cigar I find that the flavors show some transitioning from the second third and it is delivering a nice coffee and cream like flavor. The cream is showing some peppery qualities as well, and it is paired with some hay, leather and toast notes. It is a nice finish to the cigar and the flavors are really top notch in the end. I wish the first and second third were showing some of these qualities, but they were still great third and nice build ups for the finale. The construction remains top notch in the final third and it is showing that even burn line with the solid charcoal ash on the end. The ash holds on well and with that is a great bit of smoke being produced. The draw is cool, showing lots of flavors, and it is a smooth finish that is lovely and unique in some ways to the wrapper. Overall, the final third has a strength and body level around that full level, and this is not a cigar for a novice.
It has been a while since E.P. Carrillo has released a cigar that has really wowed me like some of his older stuff, but with this new release I see the company getting back on track. It was a blend that used great tobacco and he truly blended a great limited release. The construction on the cigar was top notch and overall this was a full body and full strength cigar. With those full qualities were matching flavors and they were flavors that I like to see in a cigar. I found it interesting that Dominican tobacco was not used in the blend, but at the same time it is about creating a great cigar and not necessarily using tobacco from the country you are in. The pepper flavors remained present with the cigar from beginning to end, but they were accompanied by a variety of other flavors that added to the overall flavor profile. I am giving this cigar a 92 rating but in time I think it will get even better.
Seth's Humidor Rating: 92